Miller declines to discuss reported Meta deal as publishers warn against weakening law
The culture minister refused to comment on a report that Meta and Ottawa were close to a deal before U.S.-Canada trade talks collapsed.
OTTAWA · Culture Minister Marc Miller said Wednesday he will not discuss any government talks with Meta about restoring news content to its platforms in Canada. His refusal to comment came a day after Politico reported the company and the government were close to a deal before trade negotiations with the United States collapsed in August. Miller told reporters the discussions with Meta are confidential. “Meta could always put news back online. They are the ones who removed it,” he said in French.
Politico, citing an unnamed official, reported Meta had put forward a proposal that would see it stop blocking news content in Canada, pursue commercial deals with publishers and fund two positions at the Canadian Journalism Collective. In exchange, it would obtain an exemption from the Online News Act. That law, which came into force in 2023, requires Meta and Google to compensate news publishers for the use of their content. Meta blocked news from its platforms, including Facebook and Instagram, after the law was passed.
Google already has an exemption from the act after agreeing to pay $100 million to Canadian news outlets. Politico reported the Meta proposal was part of the wider U.S.-Canada trade negotiations. Ottawa shut down those talks in August after accusing the White House of demanding last-minute changes that threatened Canada’s sovereignty. Meta declined to comment on the Politico report Wednesday.
READ MORE: Canadian automakers split on strategy as Ottawa resumes U.S. tariff talks
READ MORE: Carney pursues trade, investment at Commonwealth summit in Antigua
Publishers demand fair compensation
News industry representatives reacted cautiously to the report of a potential deal, emphasizing that any exemption for Meta must come with fair compensation. Paul Deegan, president and CEO of the publishers’ group News Media Canada, said in an email Meta should only be exempt if the company provides “fair compensation to Canadian news businesses just as Google has. They should not get our content for free.” He added that “Canada should not return to the dark days prior to the Online News Act when Google and Meta were picking the winners and losers” in Canadian media.
In a brief interview, Deegan elaborated on that concern. He said before the Online News Act became law, Google and Meta were signing content licensing agreements with large news publishers but not with smaller independent publishers. “You don’t want to have a situation where they’re only doing deals with the few, and then frankly potentially have outside influence with some of those publishers,” Deegan said. “Whereas if they’re doing deals with everyone, then everyone is under the same terms. And that’s really our concern if there’s any weakening of the Online News Act.”
Broadcasters echo call for value
Kevin Desjardins, president and CEO of the Canadian Association of Broadcasters, offered a measured response to the Politico report. He said in an email a “deal is never a deal until it’s done, and how ‘close’ it was is in the eye of the beholder.” Desjardins said the door has always been open to “Meta receiving an exemption from the Online News Act, as Google already has, provided that they offer something of true value to compensate news publishers for the various ways they make use of their content, including in their AI products.” The report of a potential agreement highlights the ongoing tension between the government, which passed the law to support the news industry, and Meta, which chose to remove news entirely rather than comply. Miller’s statement places the onus squarely on Meta to reverse its decision. The collapse of the broader trade talks in August appears to have halted whatever progress had been made on the Meta proposal at that time.
With files from BNN Bloomberg, Castanet and Global News