Study says high-speed rail line from Quebec City to Toronto could add $24.5 billion to GDP yearly
The economic study, commissioned by the Crown corporation behind the project, cites productivity gains from shorter travel times.
A new economic study says a proposed high-speed rail line between Quebec City and Toronto could add $24.5 billion annually to Canada's gross domestic product. The report, commissioned by the Crown corporation Alto, was released Thursday by the Montreal-based consulting firm Aviseo Conseil. It says the gains would come primarily from improved productivity driven by shorter travel times, better access to jobs and talent, easier in-person meetings and reduced travel costs. Economist Jean-Pierre Lessard, a partner and co-founder of Aviseo, said the train would reduce "economic distance" and bring businesses and clients closer together.
"This creates significant productivity gains that ripple throughout the entire economy, and that’s how we arrive at $24.5 billion year after year," Lessard said. He said his firm's estimates on the value of the proposed train line represent around one per cent of the country's GDP. "It’s as if we were adding an extra six months of economic growth per year to the Canadian economy," he said. The 1,000-kilometre Alto project would connect Quebec City, Trois-Rivières, Laval, Montreal, Ottawa, Peterborough and Toronto, with a station in Kingston still under consideration. The line, running on new dedicated tracks at speeds up to 300 km/h, would connect Montreal and Toronto in three hours and complete the full Quebec City to Toronto journey in four and a half hours. The federal government announced in February 2025 it was moving forward with the project.
The study identifies the Quebec City-Toronto corridor as Canada's main economic centre, housing 41 per cent of the population and generating 40 per cent of national GDP. It says the corridor's current transportation networks face growing constraints in cost, time and reliability. Air travel suffers from limited competition, the report claims, while VIA Rail must share tracks with and yield to freight traffic. Aviseo's analysis also warns of a cost to inaction. It says about 80 million intercity trips are made annually on the proposed route today, a number projected to rise to 115 million by 2059. "Without high-speed rail, this growth would be absorbed by existing networks, whose investment needs could exceed $50 billion for Québec and Ontario combined by 2050 under a status quo scenario," the firm said. Lessard said that without the train, travel demand will increase by 44 per cent on already saturated infrastructure. "We’ll have to add highway lanes, build overpasses, add new exits, and even build a new highway," he said, adding that such new infrastructure would still not be as fast as the proposed train.
READ MORE: Quebec regions nearly match Ontario's economic output, but Montreal lags Toronto
READ MORE: Anthropic prices IPO at $83 US per share in record $81.3 billion offering
The report bases its conclusions on analyses from the past 50 years and the implementation of high-speed rail in over 20 countries. It says its work was reviewed by an independent committee of four experts from different universities across Canada. Lessard defended the value of the analysis, stating, "I don’t think we’d risk our reputation for the sake of marketing. It’s based on the most up-to-date literature available on international experiences."
While the report analyzes benefits, Lessard said information on the project's cost is still unknown. Alto estimates it would cost between $60 billion and $90 billion. The Parliamentary Budget Officer earlier this year put the cost at $75 billion to $113 billion, and some experts have cited a figure of $150 billion. Lessard said the objective of his firm's study was not a cost-benefit analysis. "We’re focusing on the economic benefits as a whole, and what we see is that they are significant," he said.
The project has faced opposition from the Conservative party, residents living along the proposed route and agricultural organizations from Quebec, Ontario and Canada. These groups have called on Ottawa to revisit the project, saying it could cost far more than projected and cause significant damage to agricultural land. Alto is aiming to begin construction on the first phase, connecting Montreal to Ottawa, in 2029. That phase is expected to take eight years to complete.
With files from The Canadian Press, Narcity and BNN Bloomberg